Here In Berks
Home / Blog

The Best Italian Restaurants in Reading, PA

The top pick is Mimmo's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria on Morgantown Road. It has the most reviews by a wide margin, about 1,960, and holds a 4.6 rating, with diners consistently praising the portions, the homemade pasta and the service. Mom Chaffe's Cellarette and Sebastiano's rate slightly higher at 4.7, so a smaller, quieter dinner is worth a look too.

1. Mimmo's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria (Reading)

★ 4.6 from 1,963 Google reviews
290 Morgantown Rd, Reading, PA 19611
Hours, photos and details

Mimmo's is a family-run Italian restaurant at 290 Morgantown Rd. It has a casual, cozy dining room and a patio with a waterfall, and it also handles catering and events, including a private dining room.

Reviewers most often mention generous portions, homemade pasta and desserts, and attentive service. The patio and the atmosphere in the event rooms come up repeatedly. A few people feel the prices run high for the portion or flavor.

It is open Tuesday through Sunday and closed Mondays, with later hours on Friday and Saturday. Takeout, delivery and outdoor seating are all available, and reservations are accepted. Prices run about $10 to $50.

2. Mom Chaffe's Cellarette (Reading)

★ 4.7 from 575 Google reviews
148 Tulpehocken Ave, Reading, PA 19611
Hours, photos and details

Mom Chaffe's is an old-world Italian restaurant with a bar at 148 Tulpehocken Ave. The menu centers on traditional pasta plates and pizzas, along with cocktails, wine, coffee and dessert.

Reviewers consistently praise the food, especially the pasta and desserts, and describe the atmosphere as cozy, warm and eclectic. Several also say the space is small and can get loud, and that service can be inconsistent.

It is open for dinner only, Monday through Saturday, and closed Sundays. Dinner reservations are recommended. Takeout is available, and prices run about $20 to $60. With a 4.7 rating from about 575 reviews, it is a good fit for a planned evening out.

3. Nino's - Pizza & Italian Restaurant (Reading)

★ 4.6 from 967 Google reviews
515 Richmond St, Reading, PA 19605
Hours, photos and details

Nino's is a family-owned spot at 515 Richmond St that has served Neapolitan pizza and Italian entrees since 1993. It is casual and cozy, with beer, wine and cocktails, plus catering and a private dining room.

Reviewers often describe friendly staff, good portions and a cozy family atmosphere. Several mention easy online ordering and quick service. A few say their concerns about a meal or delivery were not resolved to their satisfaction.

This is one of the more convenient options for hours. It opens at 10 AM Monday through Saturday and at noon on Sunday, closing at 9 or 10 PM on most days. Dine-in, takeout and delivery are all offered, and prices run about $10 to $20.

4. Sebastiano's Italian Restaurant And Pizzeria (Reading)

★ 4.7 from 489 Google reviews
3227 Perkiomen Ave, Reading, PA 19606
Hours, photos and details

Sebastiano's is an informal Italian restaurant at 3227 Perkiomen Ave. The menu ranges from pizza and subs to pasta and seafood entrees, with a salad bar, small plates, coffee and dessert.

Reviewers consistently call the food tasty, authentic and comforting, with homemade sauce and fresh bread often mentioned. Service is described as friendly and accommodating, and prices are generally seen as reasonable.

It serves lunch and dinner Tuesday through Sunday and is closed Mondays. The kitchen closes at 8:30 PM, earlier than most places on this list, so plan accordingly. Dine-in, takeout and catering are available, and reservations are accepted. It holds a 4.7 rating from about 490 reviews.

5. Anthony's Trattoria (Reading)

★ 4.5 from 656 Google reviews
900 Byram St, Reading, PA 19606
Hours, photos and details

Anthony's Trattoria is an old-fashioned Italian restaurant at 900 Byram St with a full bar, coffee and desserts. It offers outdoor patio seating and a private dining room.

Reviewers often praise the traditional Italian food, and several mention standout dishes and desserts. A few describe the atmosphere as upscale and worth the visit. Some feel the food quality does not fully match the prices, and a few mention the restaurant is loud. The building's appearance draws mixed comments.

It is open every day except Monday, from noon to 10 PM, which makes it a rare Sunday option for a full dinner. Dinner reservations are recommended. Prices run about $20 to $70, and takeout and delivery are available.

6. Esposito's - Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria (Reading)

★ 4.5 from 624 Google reviews
1540 Friedensburg Rd, Reading, PA 19606
Hours, photos and details

Esposito's is an Italian restaurant and pizzeria at 1540 Friedensburg Rd with a bar, a private dining room and catering. It has live music listed among its highlights.

Reviewers consistently describe the staff as friendly, attentive and welcoming. They praise the quality ingredients, well-cooked pasta and generous portions at reasonable prices. Several name the pizza and chicken parmesan as standouts, and many say they return often or recommend it to others.

It is open seven days a week, with Friday and Saturday hours starting at 7:30 AM. Dine-in, takeout, delivery and curbside pickup are all offered, and there are vegan and vegetarian options. Prices run about $10 to $20.

7. Gino's Cafe Italian Restaurant Pizzeria And Catering (Reading)

★ 4.5 from 484 Google reviews
400 W Broad St, Reading, PA 19607
Hours, photos and details

Gino's is an Italian restaurant and pizzeria at 400 W Broad St. The menu includes comfort food, small plates, vegetarian options, beer, wine and desserts, and it also does catering.

Reviewers often praise the chicken parmesan, cheesesteaks, soups and desserts, and several describe the service as good. Some feel portion sizes and sauce amounts have not matched the price, and a few say recent wings and orders were not as good as before.

It is open every day, from 10:30 AM to 9 PM most days and until 10 PM on Friday and Saturday. Dine-in, takeout and delivery are available, and reservations are accepted. Prices run about $10 to $20.

8. Stefano's Ristorante & Bakery Café (Reading)

★ 4.6 from 214 Google reviews
1816 State Hill Rd, Reading, PA 19610
Hours, photos and details

Stefano's is an Italian restaurant and bakery café at 1816 State Hill Rd. It serves lunch, brunch and dinner, along with coffee, desserts, takeout and catering. The space is cozy and casual, with a fireplace and outdoor seating.

Reviewers consistently praise the food, describing fresh homemade pasta, generous portions and well-prepared dishes. They also appreciate the friendly, welcoming staff and the warm, family-friendly atmosphere.

It is open daily from 11 AM, closing at 9 PM or 10 PM on Friday and Saturday, and reservations are accepted. Prices run about $20 to $30. It has the fewest reviews on this list, about 214, so its 4.6 rating rests on a smaller sample.

How we picked

We ranked these restaurants by Google star rating, adjusted for the number of reviews, so a high score from a few hundred reviews counts for less than the same score from a few thousand. National chains are left out, and nobody paid to be included. The data was checked in November 2026.

Quick answers

Which Italian restaurants in Reading are open on Sunday? Mimmo's, Nino's, Sebastiano's, Anthony's Trattoria, Esposito's, Gino's Cafe and Stefano's are all open Sunday. Mom Chaffe's Cellarette is closed Sundays.

Which ones offer takeout? All eight list takeout. Mimmo's, Nino's, Anthony's Trattoria, Esposito's, Gino's Cafe and Mom Chaffe's also list delivery or no-contact delivery, and Esposito's adds curbside pickup.

Which is the highest rated? Mom Chaffe's Cellarette and Sebastiano's both have a 4.7 rating. Mimmo's ranks first overall because its rating comes from far more reviews.

More from the blog