Trego Insurance Agency in Wyomissing is our top pick, with a perfect 5-star rating across 299 reviews. Customers describe a helpful staff that turns quotes around quickly and has lowered premiums for several of them. The rest of the list is close behind, and most of it is clustered in and around Wyomissing.
1. Trego Insurance Agency LLC (Wyomissing)
1100 Berkshire Blvd Suite 205, Wyomissing, PA 19610
Hours, photos and details
Trego Insurance Agency is at 1100 Berkshire Blvd, Suite 205, in Wyomissing. It handles auto, home, and life insurance, and it holds a 5-star Google rating from 299 reviews.
Reviewers keep coming back to the same few points. The staff is helpful and quick to provide quotes, and several people say the team found ways to lower what they were paying. Others mention that it is easy to get an answer by phone or email without chasing anyone down.
The office is open Monday through Friday, 8 AM to 4 PM, and closed on weekends. That is an earlier close than most agencies on this list, so plan calls for the day.
2. Perfetto Insurance (Wyomissing)
★ 4.9 from 351 Google reviews40 Commerce Dr, Wyomissing, PA 19610
Hours, photos and details
Perfetto Insurance is at 40 Commerce Dr in Wyomissing. It is listed for auto, home, health, dental, and general insurance, and it also operates as an insurance company. The rating is 4.9 from 351 reviews, the largest count on this list.
Reviewers single out the agents' knowledge of Medicare and Medicare supplement plans. Many say the staff made a confusing process less stressful and explained things clearly without pushing them toward a particular plan.
Appointments are required here. You can book online or be seen onsite. Hours are Monday through Friday, 8:30 AM to 5 PM, and the office is closed Saturday and Sunday.
3. Blue Marsh Insurance, Inc. (Fleetwood)
430 Park Rd, Fleetwood, PA 19522
Hours, photos and details
The Fleetwood office of Blue Marsh Insurance is at 430 Park Rd. The agency offers auto, home, dental, health, Medicare-related, and income protection insurance. It has a 4.9 rating from 315 reviews.
Customers describe a knowledgeable, professional, and responsive team. Reviewers often say the staff explains coverage options plainly, and several mention finding better coverage or lower annual premiums. Efficient help with claims comes up as well.
You can make an appointment online or stop in for onsite service. The office is open Monday through Friday, 9 AM to 5 PM, and closed on weekends.
4. Spotts Insurance (Wyomissing)
74 Commerce Dr, Wyomissing, PA 19610
Hours, photos and details
Spotts Insurance is at 74 Commerce Dr in Wyomissing. It is listed as an auto insurance agency and also offers home insurance, life insurance, and insurance brokerage services. The rating is 4.9 from 288 reviews.
Many reviewers say they have been clients for years. They describe helpful, knowledgeable agents who respond quickly and go out of their way to find better rates or coverage. A few also note that the agents make it easier to deal with a larger insurer.
Hours are Monday through Friday, 9 AM to 5 PM, with weekends closed.
5. Blue Marsh Insurance, Inc. (Morgantown)
3319 Main St, Morgantown, PA 19543
Hours, photos and details
This is the Morgantown office of Blue Marsh Insurance, at 3319 Main St. It offers auto, home, health, dental, and income protection insurance, and it carries a 4.9 rating from 283 reviews.
Reviewers praise how quickly the agents respond and how clearly they explain coverage options. They also mention competitive rates on home and auto policies. The agents are patient with questions and walk people through switching to a new policy or setting one up.
Online appointments and onsite service are both available. The office is open Monday through Friday, 9 AM to 5 PM, and closed on weekends.
6. Reich Insurance, Inc. (Wyomissing)
200 Spring Ridge Dr #101, Wyomissing, PA 19610
Hours, photos and details
Reich Insurance is at 200 Spring Ridge Dr, Suite 101, in Wyomissing. It is listed as an insurance agency offering home and life insurance, with a 4.9 rating from 231 reviews.
Customers describe a responsive and thorough staff that takes time to explain coverage options and how claims work. Several long-time clients say they have had good experiences with the agency over many years.
The office is open Monday through Friday, 8:30 AM to 5 PM, and closed on Saturday and Sunday.
7. Stubbs Insurance Associates, Inc. (Wernersville)
301 Sportsman Rd, Wernersville, PA 19565
Hours, photos and details
Stubbs Insurance Associates is at 301 Sportsman Rd in Wernersville. It offers auto, home, life, motorcycle, and renter's insurance. It has a 5-star rating from 121 reviews, the smallest review count on this list.
Reviewers describe a friendly, knowledgeable staff that handles questions and concerns quickly and clearly. They also like having a local office with a physical location and real people who pick up the phone. Pricing is described as competitive.
Service is onsite at the office. Hours are Monday through Friday, 8:30 AM to 5 PM, with weekends closed.
8. Herb Auto Tag - PA Title & Tag Service - Boyertown (Boyertown)
138 S Reading Ave, Boyertown, PA 19512, United States
Hours, photos and details
Herb Auto Tag is at 138 S Reading Ave in Boyertown. It is a registration office that also lists services as an auto tag agency, auto insurance agency, and notary public. The rating is 4.9 from 139 reviews.
Customers describe friendly, knowledgeable, and patient staff who explain each step clearly. The recurring complaint is a long wait during busy periods, with several reviewers feeling the line was not managed to move faster.
It has the longest hours on the list: Monday through Friday, 9 AM to 8 PM, and Saturday, 9 AM to 2 PM. It is closed Sunday.
9. Spotts Insurance Group Inc (Temple)
4857 Kutztown Rd, Temple, PA 19560
Hours, photos and details
Spotts Insurance Group is at 4857 Kutztown Rd in Temple. It is listed as an auto insurance agency and also offers home, life, and general insurance agency and broker services. The rating is 4.9 from 136 reviews.
Reviewers describe patient, knowledgeable agents who are willing to explore options to find competitive rates. Many say the process felt smooth, personal, and comfortable, with the feel of a family business.
Service is onsite. Hours are Monday through Friday, 8:30 AM to 5 PM, and the office is closed on weekends.
10. MGS Insurance Agency LLC (Reading)
606 Museum Rd, Reading, PA 19611
Hours, photos and details
MGS Insurance Agency is at 606 Museum Rd in Reading. It is listed in the insurance agency category and has a website for more information. The rating is 4.9 from 127 reviews.
Reviewers describe a helpful, knowledgeable, and responsive team that explains policy details clearly and checks in regularly. Clients like that policies are reviewed each year with suggestions for coverage, and that claims are handled efficiently. Several are long-term clients.
The office is open Monday through Friday, 8:30 AM to 5 PM, and closed on Saturday and Sunday.
How we picked
We ranked agencies by Google star rating adjusted for review count, so a handful of perfect reviews does not outrank hundreds of strong ones. National chains were left out, and nobody paid to be included. The data was checked in November 2026.
Quick answers
Which agencies are open on weekends? Only Herb Auto Tag in Boyertown, which is open Saturday from 9 AM to 2 PM. Every other agency on this list is closed Saturday and Sunday.
Which agency has the highest rating? Trego Insurance Agency in Wyomissing and Stubbs Insurance Associates in Wernersville both have a perfect 5-star rating. Trego has far more reviews, 299 compared with 121.
Which agencies let you book an appointment online? Perfetto Insurance in Wyomissing and both Blue Marsh Insurance offices, in Fleetwood and Morgantown, offer online appointments. Perfetto requires an appointment for all visits.