The short answer is Sunset Mexican Ice Cream on Hiesters Lane. It has a 4.7 rating across 260 reviews, and it's the one place on this list built entirely around ice cream and sweet drinks. If you want a dessert counter that's open every evening, that's where to start. A few other spots on the list suit a cake, a coffee and pastry stop, or a park picnic better.
1. Gring's Mill Recreation Area (Reading)
2083 Tulpehocken Rd, Reading, PA 19610
Hours, photos and details
Gring's Mill is a park at 2083 Tulpehocken Rd, not a dessert shop, so treat it as a place to take your treat rather than buy one. With a 4.7 rating from 1,225 reviews, it's the most reviewed place here. Reviewers describe well-kept grounds, flat paths along the Tulpehocken River, and a peaceful setting with wildlife and clean restrooms. People use it for walking, jogging, biking and picnics.
For planning, the listed hours are Monday through Friday, 8:30 AM to 4:30 PM, and it's closed Saturday and Sunday. There's a playground, and it's listed as good for kids and kids' birthdays. Pick up something sweet elsewhere and bring it along.
2. Spenny's (Reading)
2931 Centre Ave, Reading, PA 19605
Hours, photos and details
Spenny's is a cheesesteak restaurant at 2931 Centre Ave that also serves hoagies, pizza and ice cream. It holds a 4.8 rating from 505 reviews, the highest on the list. Reviewers praise the flavorful cheesesteaks, the fresh ingredients, and friendly, prompt staff in a welcoming room. It's women-owned.
The hours run Wednesday through Saturday, 11 AM to 7 PM, and Sunday, 12 to 6 PM. It's closed Monday and Tuesday. You can dine in, order takeout or get delivery, and there's outdoor seating, high chairs and counter service. Prices fall in the $10 to $20 range. Come for a sandwich and finish with ice cream.
3. Cafe Sweet Street (Reading)
722 Hiesters Ln, Reading, PA 19605
Hours, photos and details
Cafe Sweet Street, at 722 Hiesters Ln, is a cafe with a strong dessert and baked goods side. It has a 4.6 rating from 695 reviews. Reviewers consistently praise the coffee, desserts and baked goods, along with a varied, fresh menu that rotates. Several mention friendly service, and many call it a good spot for a casual lunch or a meetup with friends or coworkers.
It's open Monday through Friday, 7 AM to 5 PM, and closed on weekends. It offers dine-in, takeout, curbside pickup and delivery, plus outdoor seating and reservations. The atmosphere is described as cozy and quiet, with vegan and vegetarian options available. Prices are listed at $10 to $20.
4. Sunset Mexican Ice Cream (Reading)
835 Hiesters Ln, Reading, PA 19605
Hours, photos and details
Sunset Mexican Ice Cream is at 835 Hiesters Ln, just down the road from Cafe Sweet Street. It's an ice cream shop and Mexican restaurant with a 4.7 rating from 260 reviews. Reviewers like the ice cream and the fruit-based drinks, along with street-style snacks such as elotes, esquites and ceviche. They also commonly mention warm, friendly staff and a charming, cozy store.
The hours are the most generous of any dessert counter here: 12 to 9 PM Monday through Saturday and 12 to 8 PM on Sunday. You can dine in, take out, use curbside pickup or get delivery. It's listed as good for kids and suited to a quick visit.
5. Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard (Reading)
1124 Lancaster Ave #30, Reading, PA 19607
Hours, photos and details
This Rita's is at 1124 Lancaster Ave #30 and holds a 4.5 rating from 263 reviews. It's a counter-serve shop known for Italian ice and frozen custard. Reviewers often praise the friendly staff and the taste of the ice. Several also say that portion sizes and the posted hours didn't always match what they found, so it's worth checking before you drive over.
It offers takeout and in-store pickup, and it's listed as good for kids and a quick visit. No hours or price range were available in the data, which is one more reason to confirm ahead.
6. Carvel (Reading)
3320 N 5th Street Hwy, Reading, PA 19605
Hours, photos and details
Carvel is at 3320 N 5th Street Hwy, with a 4.5 rating from 250 reviews. It's a long-running chain known for soft-serve and custom cakes, mostly for takeout. Reviewers consistently praise the taste and freshness of the ice cream and call it a longtime favorite. Many mention friendly, attentive service, and prices rising over time comes up often.
It's open daily, 11 AM to 9 PM, with Saturday running until 10 PM. Dine-in, takeout and delivery are all available, and it's listed as good for kids and a quick visit.
7. Ady Cakes (Reading)
631 Penn Ave, Reading, PA 19611
Hours, photos and details
Ady Cakes is a women-owned cake shop and bakery at 631 Penn Ave, rated 4.5 from 233 reviews. It makes cakes, cupcakes, cake pops, macarons and cookies, plus custom wedding orders. Reviewers consistently call the baked goods delicious and well made, with cupcakes and custom orders drawing frequent praise. They also appreciate the friendly, accommodating team, especially for special occasions.
Hours are Tuesday through Friday, 10 AM to 5 PM, and Saturday, 10 AM to 4 PM. It's closed Sunday and Monday. In-store pickup, takeout and delivery are available, and prices are listed at $1 to $10.
8. Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard (Reading)
3403 N 5th Street Hwy, Reading, PA 19605
Hours, photos and details
The second Rita's is at 3403 N 5th Street Hwy, rated 4.4 from 280 reviews. Reviewers often praise the Italian ices and gelati, and several say the service is prompt and polite. Some mention the outdoor seating area and feel it could be improved, and a few say the flavors or service on certain visits fell short.
It offers takeout and in-store pickup, with seating available, and it's listed as good for kids and a quick visit. No hours were listed in the data.
How we picked
We ranked each business by its Google star rating, adjusted for how many reviews it has. National chains were left out, and nobody paid to be included. The data was checked in November 2026.
Quick answers
Which of these are open on Sunday? Spenny's (12 to 6 PM), Sunset Mexican Ice Cream (12 to 8 PM) and Carvel (11 AM to 9 PM) list Sunday hours. Gring's Mill, Cafe Sweet Street and Ady Cakes are closed that day.
Which offer takeout? Spenny's, Cafe Sweet Street, Sunset Mexican Ice Cream, both Rita's locations, Carvel and Ady Cakes all list takeout. Gring's Mill is a park, so it doesn't.
Which is the highest rated? Spenny's leads at 4.8 stars from 505 reviews. Gring's Mill and Sunset Mexican Ice Cream follow at 4.7.