Best Italian in Reading, PA
-
Mimmo's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
Customers most often praise the portion sizes, the homemade pasta and desserts, and the attentive service. The outdoor patio and the atmosphere in the event rooms also come up repeatedly, and one complaint about pricing relative to portion or flavor appears in the reviews.
-
Mom Chaffe's Cellarette
Customers consistently praise the food, especially the pasta dishes and desserts, and describe the cozy, warm, eclectic atmosphere. Several reviewers also note that the restaurant is small and can get loud, and that service can be inconsistent.
-
Nino's - Pizza & Italian Restaurant
Customers often describe friendly staff, good portions, and a cozy family atmosphere, with several noting easy online ordering and quick service. A few reviewers mention that their concerns about a meal or delivery were not resolved to their satisfaction.
-
Pizza Italia
Customers often praise the classic, generous food, especially the pizza, and say the prices feel fair for what they get. Several reviewers also describe the place as a friendly, old-school spot with a welcoming staff, though a couple of reviewers report being charged more than the posted menu prices at the register.
-
Sebastiano's Italian Restaurant And Pizzeria
Reviewers consistently describe the food as tasty, authentic and comforting, with homemade sauce and fresh bread often mentioned. Service is described as friendly and accommodating, and prices are generally considered reasonable.
-
Anthony's Trattoria
Customers often praise the Italian food, with several mentioning standout dishes and desserts, and a few describe the atmosphere as upscale and worth the visit. Some reviewers feel the food quality does not fully match the prices, and a few mention the restaurant is loud, with the building's appearance also drawing mixed comments.
-
Esposito's - Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
Customers consistently describe the staff as friendly, attentive, and welcoming, and they often praise the food for its quality ingredients, well-cooked pasta, and generous portions at reasonable prices. Several reviewers name the pizza, chicken parmesan, and other Italian dishes as standouts, and many say they return often or recommend the restaurant to others.
-
Gino's Cafe Italian Restaurant Pizzeria And Catering
Customers often praise the food, including the chicken parmesan, cheesesteaks, soups and desserts, and several describe the service as good. Some reviewers feel portion sizes and sauce amounts have not matched the price, and a few say recent wings and orders were not as good as before.
-
Stefano's Ristorante & Bakery Café
Customers consistently praise the food, describing fresh homemade pasta, generous portions, and well-prepared dishes. Reviewers also appreciate the friendly, welcoming staff and the warm, family-friendly atmosphere.
-
Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard
Customers often praise the friendly staff and the taste of the Italian ice. Several reviewers say portion sizes and posted hours do not always match what they experienced.
Featured partners and our picks are listed first. Everything after them is ranked by Google star rating, adjusted for how many people left a review, with national chains left out. Checked November 2026.
Quick answers
What is the best italian in Reading?
Based on Google ratings and review counts, the top-rated is Mimmo's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria in Reading (4.6 stars from 1,963 reviews), followed by Mom Chaffe's Cellarette in Reading, Nino's - Pizza & Italian Restaurant in Reading, Pizza Italia in Reading.
Which of the best italian in Reading are open on Sunday?
Mimmo's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria, Nino's - Pizza & Italian Restaurant, Sebastiano's Italian Restaurant And Pizzeria list Sunday hours on Google.